Schedules of Reinforcement in ABA: The 4 Types, With a Simulator
The four schedules of reinforcement, continuous vs. intermittent, compound and time-based schedules, and what research says. Try each one in the simulator.
Key Takeaways
- 01A schedule of reinforcement is the rule that decides which responses produce a reinforcer. Continuous reinforcement reinforces every response; intermittent schedules reinforce only some.
- 02The four basic intermittent schedules are fixed ratio, variable ratio, fixed interval and variable interval. Ratio schedules count responses and interval schedules count time.
- 03Fixed-time and variable-time schedules deliver reinforcers on the clock with no response required, which makes them different from interval schedules.
- 04Concurrent, multiple, mixed and chained schedules combine simple ones. The BCBA outline tests simple schedules in B.9 and these in B.10.
- 05In Hanley, Iwata and Thompson (2001), a fixed-interval schedule produced undesirably high rates of a newly taught request, while a signaled multiple schedule kept it at moderate, stable levels.
Schedules of reinforcement are the rules that decide which responses produce a reinforcer. Reinforce every response and you have continuous reinforcement. Reinforce only some, based on a count of responses or the passage of time, and you have an intermittent schedule, of which the four basic types are fixed ratio, variable ratio, fixed interval and variable interval. Each produces its own pattern of behavior, and you can see those patterns for yourself in the simulator below.
Try the Schedules Yourself
Reading that a variable ratio "produces high, steady responding" is one thing. Feeling yourself click faster because the next click might pay off is another. Pick a schedule, respond for a minute, then try a different one and compare the lines on the chart.
Schedule of Reinforcement Simulator
You are the learner. Pick a schedule, then click Respond as often as you like for 60 seconds. A star means that response was reinforced. Run a few schedules and compare the lines.
- Responses
- 0
- Reinforcers
- 0
- Time left
- 60 s
Cumulative record: the line climbs one step per response and goes flat when you stop. Short slanted ticks mark reinforcers. Earlier runs stay on the chart, faded.
| Schedule | Responses | Reinforcers | Responses per reinforcer |
|---|
Try fixed interval after variable ratio. Most people notice within a few reinforcers that clicking early on FI does nothing, and they start waiting, then clicking quickly as they think the 10 seconds are nearly up. That's the scallop in the table below, produced by you instead of a pigeon.
What Is a Schedule of Reinforcement?
A schedule of reinforcement is the contingency between responses and reinforcers: which responses, or which responses at what time, get reinforced. The systematic study of schedules goes back to Charles Ferster and B. F. Skinner's Schedules of Reinforcement, first published in 1957, in which they examined how different schedules shaped the behavior of pigeons. The patterns they recorded turned out to apply to people too, and they're now part of every behavior analyst's basic vocabulary.
In ABA, schedules matter for two practical reasons. The schedule a skill is taught on affects how fast it's learned and how well it lasts. And the schedule a problem behavior has been on affects what happens when you try to change it.
Continuous vs. Intermittent Reinforcement
Continuous reinforcement (CRF) reinforces every response. It's also written FR 1, a fixed ratio of one. CRF is the usual choice while a skill is being acquired, because the learner contacts the contingency every time they respond correctly.
Intermittent reinforcement reinforces some responses and not others. It's what most behavior meets in daily life, since no teacher or parent can reinforce every correct response forever. It also tends to produce behavior that persists longer once reinforcement stops. In the words of Lerman, Iwata, Shore and Kahng (1996), basic research has shown that behavior maintained on an intermittent schedule "will be extinguished more slowly" than behavior maintained on continuous reinforcement.
The usual plan in ABA follows from both points: teach on continuous reinforcement, then move gradually to an intermittent schedule once the skill is reliable. That gradual move is called schedule thinning.
The 4 Basic Schedules of Reinforcement
The four basic intermittent schedules come from two yes-or-no questions. Does the rule count responses (ratio) or time (interval)? And is the requirement the same every time (fixed) or does it change around an average (variable)?
| Schedule | The rule | Typical pattern | ABA example | Everyday example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed ratio (FR) | A reinforcer after a set number of responses. FR 5 means every fifth response. | Fast, steady responding, with a pause after each reinforcer that gets longer as the ratio gets larger. | A learner earns a token after every three correctly matched cards. | A loyalty card that gives a free coffee after ten purchases. |
| Variable ratio (VR) | A reinforcer after a number of responses that changes from one reinforcer to the next, around an average. VR 5 averages five. | High, steady responding with little or no pause, because the next response could always be the one. | During independent work, praise comes after roughly every fourth correct answer, sometimes after two, sometimes after six. | A slot machine, or a salesperson closing some calls and not others. |
| Fixed interval (FI) | The first response after a set amount of time is reinforced. Responses before the time is up do nothing. | Little responding just after a reinforcer, speeding up as the interval runs out. On a cumulative record this curve is called a scallop. | A check-in every 5 minutes: the first time the learner raises a hand after 5 minutes, they get a break. | Checking the oven more often as the timer gets close. |
| Variable interval (VI) | The first response after an amount of time that changes around an average is reinforced. VI 2 minutes averages 2 minutes. | Moderate, steady responding with few pauses, because a reinforcer could become available at any moment. | A teacher scans the room at unpredictable times and praises the first student seen working. | Checking a phone for a reply that could arrive any time. |
Two points trip people up on exams. First, interval schedules still require a response. Nothing is delivered just because the time passed; the time only makes the next response eligible. Second, the number in a variable schedule is an average. VR 5 doesn't mean "five responses, plus or minus a bit"; the requirement could be 1 one time and 9 the next.
The patterns in the table are the textbook descriptions, from laboratory work going back to Ferster and Skinner. Real learners in real sessions are noisier, and the schedule is only one of the things controlling their behavior. Motivation, effort and competing reinforcers all play a part.
Time-Based Schedules: Fixed Time and Variable Time
Fixed-time (FT) and variable-time (VT) schedules deliver a reinforcer when the time is up, whatever the learner is doing. No response is required, which is the whole difference from fixed and variable interval. On FI 2 minutes, the learner has to respond after 2 minutes to get the reinforcer. On FT 2 minutes, the reinforcer simply arrives every 2 minutes.
Time-based schedules are how noncontingent reinforcement (NCR) is usually run. If an assessment shows a learner's behavior is maintained by attention, giving attention on an FT schedule reduces the motivation to get it through problem behavior. The BCBA outline lists designing and evaluating these schedules as task G.3. They're also easy to confuse with differential reinforcement of other behavior (DRO), which runs on a timer too but only delivers the reinforcer if the target behavior hasn't happened.
Compound Schedules: Concurrent, Multiple, Mixed and Chained
Compound schedules combine two or more simple schedules. The BCBA outline asks you to tell four of them apart.
| Schedule | How it works | Signaled? | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concurrent | Two or more schedules run at the same time, each for a different response. The learner chooses where to respond. | Each option has its own stimulus | Asking for a break pays off on FR 1 while screaming pays off now and then. Where behavior goes depends on the payoff for each. |
| Multiple | Two or more schedules alternate for the same response, and each one has its own signal. | Yes | A green card on the desk means requests for attention are honored; a red card means the adult is busy. |
| Mixed | Like a multiple schedule, but the schedules alternate with no signal. | No | The same alternation as above with no card, so the learner can't tell which period it is. |
| Chained | Two or more schedules must be completed in order, and only the last one ends in the reinforcer. Each link has its own signal. | Yes | Finishing a worksheet (FR) turns on the timer for a sticker check (FI); only the sticker check produces the reinforcer. |
Concurrent schedules explain a lot of what happens in treatment. If a newly taught request for a break and an old problem behavior both produce a break, the learner is choosing between two schedules, and the richer, easier one tends to win. That's why plans for functional communication training reinforce the request on a dense schedule and place the problem behavior on extinction.
Multiple and mixed schedules differ only in the signal, and the next section shows why that signal can matter in practice. Two related terms you may meet: a tandem schedule is a chained schedule without signals, and a conjunctive schedule requires both a ratio and an interval to be met.
What Applied Research Says About Schedules
Two studies from the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis show how the textbook patterns play out with real clients.
Intermittent reinforcement and extinction. If intermittently reinforced behavior is slower to extinguish, problem behavior that has been reinforced only now and then should be harder to treat with extinction. Lerman and colleagues (1996) tested that with three individuals whose self-injury, aggression or disruption had been functionally assessed, comparing extinction after continuous and after intermittent reinforcement. Their results suggested problem behavior "may not be more difficult to treat with extinction" after an intermittent schedule. They also found that switching from an intermittent schedule to a continuous one before starting extinction may lower both the baseline rate and the total number of responses during extinction.
Thinning a newly taught request. Hanley, Iwata and Thompson (2001) treated three participants with functional communication training, reinforcing the new request on FR 1, then tried four ways to make reinforcement less frequent. Increasing the delay to reinforcement extinguished the request. A fixed-interval schedule "produced undesirably high rates" of it. A multiple schedule, with signaled periods of reinforcement and extinction, kept the request at moderate, stable levels, and for the other two participants the signals in the multiple schedule made thinning easier than an unsignaled mixed schedule. By the end of treatment, problem behavior stayed low or at zero under a multiple schedule of a 4-minute extinction period followed by a 1-minute reinforcement period.
The practical lesson: the simple schedules aren't always the best tools for thinning. When a learner can't get a reinforcer every time they ask, telling them when it is and isn't available can work better than leaving them to guess.
Schedules of Reinforcement on the RBT and BCBA Exams
On the RBT exam, schedules fall under task C.1 of the RBT Test Content Outline (3rd ed.): "Implement positive and negative reinforcement procedures (e.g., immediately, contingently, according to schedules of reinforcement)." It sits in Behavior Acquisition, which carries 19 of the 75 scored questions. RBTs run the schedule written in the plan; choosing and changing it is the supervising BCBA's job.
The BCBA Test Content Outline (6th ed.) covers schedules in five tasks:
- B.9: Identify and distinguish among simple schedules of reinforcement.
- B.10: Identify and distinguish among concurrent, multiple, mixed, and chained schedules of reinforcement.
- G.3: Design and evaluate time-based reinforcement (e.g., fixed-time) schedules.
- G.4: Identify procedures to establish and use conditioned reinforcers (e.g., token economies).
- G.16: Design and evaluate procedures to maintain desired behavior change following intervention (e.g., schedule thinning, transferring to naturally occurring reinforcers).
Our guide to the BCBA task list 6th edition has the full outline.
Schedules of Reinforcement Practice Questions
These five are original questions written for this page. They aren't taken from any BACB exam. For a full-length set, try our RBT practice exam.
1. An RBT gives a learner a token after the learner completes 4, then 7, then 2, then 5 puzzle pieces. Which schedule is this?
- A.Fixed ratio 4
- B.Variable ratio 4.5
- C.Variable interval
- D.Fixed interval
Show the answer
B. Variable ratio 4.5. Reinforcement depends on the number of responses, so it's a ratio schedule, and the number changes, so it's variable. The requirements average (4 + 7 + 2 + 5) / 4 = 4.5.
2. On a cumulative record, responding is near zero right after each reinforcer and speeds up until the next one. Which schedule most likely produced it?
- A.Variable ratio
- B.Continuous reinforcement
- C.Fixed interval
- D.Variable interval
Show the answer
C. Fixed interval. That curve is the fixed-interval scallop. Responding early in the interval never pays off, so it drops after each reinforcer and picks up as the interval runs out.
3. A learner gets 30 seconds with a tablet every 3 minutes, whether or not they have engaged in any particular behavior. Which schedule is this?
- A.Fixed interval 3 minutes
- B.Fixed time 3 minutes
- C.Fixed ratio 3
- D.Differential reinforcement of other behavior
Show the answer
B. Fixed time 3 minutes. Nothing has to happen for the reinforcer to arrive, so it's a time-based schedule. A fixed-interval schedule would need a response after the 3 minutes were up, and DRO would need the target behavior to be absent.
4. During break periods signaled by a green wristband, requests are honored; during work periods signaled by a red wristband, they aren't. What is this arrangement?
- A.A mixed schedule
- B.A concurrent schedule
- C.A chained schedule
- D.A multiple schedule
Show the answer
D. A multiple schedule. The same response alternates between two schedules, each with its own signal, which makes it a multiple schedule. Without the wristbands it would be a mixed schedule.
5. A new skill is just starting to show up. What schedule fits best for now?
- A.Continuous reinforcement
- B.Variable ratio 10
- C.Variable interval 5 minutes
- D.Extinction
Show the answer
A. Continuous reinforcement. Reinforcing every correct response is the usual choice while a skill is being acquired, so the learner contacts the contingency each time. Intermittent schedules come later, once the skill is reliable, to make it last and to move it toward natural rates of reinforcement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the 4 schedules of reinforcement? +
What is a schedule of reinforcement in ABA? +
Which schedule of reinforcement is most resistant to extinction? +
What is the difference between fixed interval and fixed time? +
What is schedule thinning? +
Sources
Last checked November 19, 2026.
- Lerman, Iwata, Shore and Kahng, Responding maintained by intermittent reinforcement: implications for the use of extinction with problem behavior in clinical settings (Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 29(2):153-171, 1996)
- Hanley, Iwata and Thompson, Reinforcement schedule thinning following treatment with functional communication training (Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 34(1):17-38, 2001)
- B. F. Skinner Foundation, Ferster and Skinner, Schedules of Reinforcement (originally published 1957)
- BACB, RBT Test Content Outline (3rd ed.), task C.1
- BACB, BCBA Test Content Outline (6th ed.), tasks B.9, B.10, G.3, G.4 and G.16
Keep going
Explore ABA programs
Ready to take the next step? Browse our expert-ranked program listings.